Feature Report: Greater Paris: Combining History with a Vision of the Future

2 items of content in this feature report

Tell me more

Close-up

The Grand Paris Project, a 20-Year Endeavor

The Grand Paris project, which is expected to span two decades, is designed to create a unified conurbation that is seven times bigger than the current city of Paris, with a population 3.5 times larger. The challenge will be to transform a region hitherto characterized by hub-and-spoke development, with rail lines and roads radiating out from the center, into a homogenous territory.

Société du Grand Paris/Pont de Bondy station (Line 15 East) designed by BIG and Silvio d'Ascia (image from the competition)
Four new major metro lines with 68 stations form the backbone of the Grand Paris project. Pictured here is the proposed Pont de Bondy station (architect: Silvio d'Ascia). ©BIG - Silvio d'Ascia

Paris intra-muros, that is, the part of the city within the now-vanished walls that draws tourists from around the world, is an extremely compact area of 100 square kilometers, with a population of just over 2.2 million. Its image as an enclosed city is accentuated by the grands boulevards built along the paths of the old fortifications, the ring road and the new circular tramway.

Greater Paris (Grand Paris) will include the City of Paris, the three inner-suburb departments of Seine-Saint-Denis, Hauts-de-Seine and Val-de-Marne and several districts located further on the outskirts. Together they will create a territory that is seven times the size of historic Paris. The Paris metropolitan area, once enlarged, will still be smaller than Groß Berlin (880 square kilometers) and Outer London (1,250 square kilometers). It will have a population of 7.5 million, or more than half the population of the Île-de-France region, and account for 25% of the nation’s wealth. It will be divided into administrative territories of at least 300,000 inhabitants. The city of Paris will form a territory.1

The project aims to confirm Paris’s status as a global economic metropolis and a showcase for sustainable urban development. The city’s successful 2024 Olympics bid and quest to build its reputation as a leading European financial center after Brexit have strengthened its resolve to shed its image as a living museum. Another project goal is to improve the quality of life in the suburbs, mainly by improving housing and transportation solutions.

The Project Backbone: A New Transit System

The greatest challenge involves breaking away from the traditional radial-layout vision that has characterized the urban development of Paris. The “new cities” built in the 1960s are poorly connected to each other, and transportation routes to central Paris are inefficient and congested.

The cornerstone of the Grand Paris project is a new rapid transit system with four automated lines forming a large loop around the capital. Dubbed the Grand Paris Express,2 the system will comprise 200 kilometers running both underground and on the surface. The new routes will alleviate traffic on the existing RER commuter lines that converge in the city center and simplify travel between the suburbs. (Indeed, the sharp distinction between the city and the suburbs will fade under this less centralized system.)

The new lines will also siphon traffic from the highways and lower the number of cars entering Paris proper. In January 2018, municipal authorities rejected the idea of introducing a congestion charge, like the urban toll systems that exist in London and the Swedish city of Gothenburg. However, the French government is drafting legislation that could facilitate the introduction of similar schemes that use cameras to register license plate numbers.

The new rapid transit lines will be interconnected with the existing metro and RER networks and provide faster links to the airports and the La Défense business district. They will connect employment areas with seven regional business hubs, which will be organized around specific themes, according to the cluster concept. A total of 68 new stations are scheduled to be built by 2035. Located in the heart of residential and commercial areas, they will play an important role in urban upgrade projects. Timeframes and public investment details were still being negotiated as of January 2018.

68: The number of new stations in the Greater Paris public transportation plan.

Three Paths to Energy Efficiency

The Grand Paris Express should directly reduce energy consumption by making it easier for commuters to switch from car travel to public transportation.

As part of the project, a local energy plan was methodically drawn up using a cartographic system to plot out the details of the metropolitan area. The resulting interactive map can be viewed online.3 It provides precise details about buildings and homes based on their status, date of construction and energy use. It also inventories existing district heating networks and identifies geothermalDescribes the technology used to tap subsurface heat to produce energy... and solar energy potential.

On the basis of this tool, three lines of action were identified:

  • Improve building envelope performance: The situation is better in Paris than in the suburbs. Buildings that use the most energy were built between 1940 and 1990, which is the case for two-thirds of the buildings in the Île-de-France region. These buildings will be given priority to undergo thermal renovation.
  • Optimize district heating: The Île-de-France region has more than 100 district heating systems that supply heatIn the field of statistical thermodynamics today, heat refers to the transfer of the thermal agitation of the particles making up matter... to the equivalent of more than one million housing units.4 The largest one (close to 50% of total production) is in Paris.5 The objective is to increase the number of equivalent housing units with access to these systems by 40% from 2009 to 2020 and raise the share of renewable energies in the network mix from 30% to 50%. The system can be expanded by hooking up buildings adjacent to an existing network or by installing new, local geothermal loops.
  • Develop local renewable energies and waste-to-energy resources: To become more energy independent, residential areas can adopt solar energy, closed geothermal (using low-depth sensors) and biomassIn the energy sector, biomass is defined as all organic matter of plant or animal origin... solutions.

With an area of 700 square kilometers, Greater Paris is close in size to Groß Berlin (880 square kilometers) but significantly smaller than Outer London (1,250 square kilometers).

Innovative Governance

The Greater Paris authority is jointly administered by the state and a metropolitan council, whose members represent the districts included in the plan. One of the challenges was to resolve differences of opinion between senior government officials and local elected officials, and to smooth out conflicts between the districts themselves. In response, 14 international teams of urban planners were asked to submit development proposals for various project sites, and the public was also encouraged to participate via two initiatives, “Draw Tomorrow’s Greater Paris” and “Reinvent the Seine”.

 

Sources:

(1) See the Métropole du Grand Paris website

(2) See the Grand Paris Express website

(3) See the map (in French only)

(4) An equivalent housing unit is calculated on the basis of the average energy consumption of a multiple dwelling unit in France. It is equal to roughly 10 megawatt-hours, based on 2015 statistics.

(5) See the district heating network map (in French only)